Second and foreign language fluency from a cognitive perspective : inefficiency and control of attention in lexical access
The present dissertation focuses on the fluency of second and foreign language (L2).
Second and foreign language use is often assessed by its fluency. However, the
connections between language proficiency and fluency are far from clear. The fluency
reasearch has tried to establish these connections, but results are varied. In the current
thesis, this question is explored within the theoretical framework of Norman
Segalowitz’s division of three types of fluency: cognitive, utterance, and perceived
fluency. The overall proposition here is that in relation to L2 proficiency, cognitive
fluency provides important insights. This is based on the theories of limited cognitive
resources, which state the more efficiently the lower-level processes work, the more
resources will be available for the higher-level processes. Therefore, the fluency with
which a language is used may in part depend on the resources available for both levels
of processing.
The thesis comprises three journal articles and a synthesis of them. As a measure
of cognitive fluency, lexical access tasks were used. Fluency was operationalised as the
efficiency of lexical access (speed and accuracy) and the resources available for the
control of attention. Speed and accuracy in both word recognition and word retrieval
in L2 were measured. The participants were Finnish learners of English as a foreign
language from Grades 4, 8, and 11; and a group of Russian-speaking learners of
Finnish as a second language from primary school. Furthermore, the relationship of L2
lexical access to L1 lexical access was examined.
In Article I, the speed of lexical access was found to explain a substantial amount
of variance (20–45%) in L2 reading comprehension and writing performance. Word
recognition rates explained literacy skills in the younger readers, whereas word
retrieval rates accounted for the literacy skills in the older students, indicating a
difference in the skill profiles. In Article II, the accuracy of lexical access added 10–17%
to the explained variance of the literacy skills, confirming the importance of accurate
lexical access in addition to the its speed in literacy skills. Furthermore, fluent L1
lexical access was found to explain variance in L2 literacy skills across all grade levels.
Article III examined inaccuracies in lexical access, which were categorised as resulting
from either inefficiency or attention-control. These were shown to have different
distributions depending on the level of language proficiency. The overall results thus
highlight a componential view of fluency, with its distinct aspects connecting to L2
proficiency in more varied ways than have been considered thus far.
...
Publisher
University of JyväskyläISBN
978-951-39-7062-8ISSN Search the Publication Forum
1459-4331Keywords
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
- Väitöskirjat [3535]
License
Related items
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
-
Aletaan alusta : luku- ja kirjoitustaidottomat aikuiset uutta kieltä oppimassa
Tammelin-Laine, Taina (University of Jyväskylä, 2014) -
The role of motor system in action-related language comprehension in L1 and L2 : An fMRI study
Tian, Lili; Chen, Hongjun; Zhao, Wei; Wu, Jianlin; Zhang, Qing; De, Ailing; Leppänen, Paavo; Cong, Fengyu; Parviainen, Tiina (Elsevier, 2020)The framework of embodied cognition has challenged the modular view of a language-cognition divide by suggesting that meaning-retrieval critically involves the sensory-motor system. Despite extensive research into the ... -
Käytössä kehittyvä kieli : paikat ja tilat suomi toisena kielenä -oppijoiden teksteissä
Mustonen, Sanna (University of Jyväskylä, 2015) -
Exploring the Relationship between CLIL and L1 Ability in Finland : Analyzing Written and Oral Production
Launonen, Peter; Roiha, Anssi; Maijala, Minna (Universidad de la Sabana, 2022)This study explores the relationship between CLIL and L1 ability in a Finnish secondary education context. The study is based on the analysis of L1 written and oral productions of four ninth-grade students (2 CLIL and 2 ... -
How Are Practice and Performance Related? Development of Reading From Age 5 to 15
van Bergen, Elsje; Vasalampi, Kati; Torppa, Minna (John Wiley & Sons, 2021)Does reading a lot lead to better reading skills, or does reading a lot follow from high initial reading skills? The authors present a longitudinal study of how much children choose to read and how well they decode and ...