Being Carried Away : Fink and Winnicott on the Locus of Playing
Taipale, J. (2021). Being Carried Away : Fink and Winnicott on the Locus of Playing. Journal of Phenomenological Psychology, 52(2), 193-217. https://doi.org/10.1163/15691624-12341391
Published in
Journal of Phenomenological PsychologyAuthors
Date
2021Copyright
© Brill, 2021
The article investigates the question of the experiential location of the area of play, comparing the accounts of Eugen Fink and Donald Winnicott. It argues that while Fink builds on the phenomenological distinction between subjective phantasy and external perception, and accordingly introduces the area of play as a hybrid realm, a peculiar combination of the two, Winnicott considers the area of play as something that underlies and developmentally precedes the experiential differentiation between phantasy and external reality. While from Fink’s viewpoint Winnicott’s model neglects a central phenomenological distinction, from Winnicott’s viewpoint Fink’s account, in turn, appears adultomorphic. Elaborating on these viewpoints in detail, the article ends up considering the conditions on which the seemingly contradictory accounts of playing could be reconciled. This at once opens a new way to assess the compatibility between phenomenology and psychoanalysis.
Publisher
BrillISSN Search the Publication Forum
0047-2662Keywords
Publication in research information system
https://converis.jyu.fi/converis/portal/detail/Publication/103513339
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
License
Related items
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
-
Leikin viemää : Fink, Winnicott ja leikin kokemuksellinen paikka
Taipale, Joona (Eurooppalaisen filosofian seura ry, 2022)Minne leikki vie meidät? Fenomenologi Eugen Finkin (1905–1975) teoria leikistä nojaa käsitteelliseen erotteluun subjektiivisen kuvittelun ja ulkoisen havainnon välillä, ja hän jäsentää leikin maailman näiden alueiden ... -
La Ilusión de contacto : introspecciones (insights) desde la carta de Winnicott a Klein de 1952
Taipale, Joona (Editorial Psimática, 2024)Using Winnicott’s theory, this article produces an account of the individual’s relation to a given conceptual framework. Whereas Winnicott’s ideas have been almost exclusively discussed in developmental and psychopathological ... -
Sammalkynä : kirjoittamalla juurtuminen
Mäki-Penttilä, Sari (Suomen kouluhistoriallinen seura, 2022)Tämä kirjoitus on saanut alkusysäyksensä luontokokemuksista ja luontokokemusten keskuudessa virinneistä pohdinnoista ja kirjoituksista, joihin toisten ajattelijoiden filosofiset, antropologiset ja ekopsykologiset näkökulmat ... -
Winnicott and the (un)integrated self
Taipale, Joona (Routledge, 2023)The capacity to relax and letting one's mind wander is one of the cornerstones of psychoanalysis. In cases where this capacity seems hindered, the reasons are characteristically sought from particular and specific inhibitions: ... -
Aesthetic imagination and animate peace
von Bonsdorff, Pauline (Routledge, 2017)