Research Perspectives : Reconsidering the Role of Research Method Guidelines for Interpretive, Mixed Methods, and Design Science Research
Siponen, M., Soliman, W., & Holtkamp, P. (2021). Research Perspectives : Reconsidering the Role of Research Method Guidelines for Interpretive, Mixed Methods, and Design Science Research. Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 22(4), Article 1. https://doi.org/10.17705/1jais.00692
Published inJournal of the Association for Information Systems
© 2020 the Authors
Information systems (IS) scholars have proposed guidelines for interpretive, mixed methods, and design science research in IS. Because many of these guidelines are also suggested for evaluating what good or rigorous research is, they may be used as a checklist in the review process. In this paper, we raise the question to what extent do research guidelines for interpretive, mixed methods, and design science research offer such evidence that they can be used to evaluate the quality of research. We argue that scholars can use these guidelines to evaluate what good research is if there is compelling evidence that they lead to certain good research outcomes. We use three well-known guidelines as examples and contend that they seem not to offer evidence such that we can use them to evaluate the quality of research. Instead, the “evidence” is often an authority argument, popularity, or examples demonstrating the applicability of the guidelines. If many research method principles we regard as authoritative in IS are largely based on speculation and opinion, we should take these guidelines less seriously in evaluating the quality of research. Our proposal does not render the guidelines useless. If the guidelines cannot offer cause-and-effect evidence for the usefulness of their principles, we propose seeing the guidelines as idealizations for pedagogical purposes, which means that reviewers cannot use these guidelines as checklists to evaluate what good research is. While our examples are from interpretive, mixed methods, and design science research, we urge the IS community to ponder to what extent other research method guidelines offer such evidence that they can be used to evaluate the quality of research ...
PublisherAssociation for Information Systems
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Reconsidering the Role of Research Method Guidelines for Qualitative, Mixed-methods, and Design Science Research Holtkamp, Philipp; Soliman, Wael; Siponen, Mikko (University of Hawai'i at Manoa, 2019)Guidelines for different qualitative research genres have been proposed in information systems (IS). As these guidelines are outlined for conducting and evaluating good research, studies may be denied publication ...
Grand theories or design guidelines? : Perspectives on the role of theory in computing education research Tedre, Matti; Pajunen, John (Association for Computing Machinery (ACM), 2023)A rich body of empirically grounded results and a solid theory base have often been viewed as signs of a mature discipline. Many disciplines have frequently debated what they should accept as legitimate kinds of theories, ...
Developing mixed methods research in sport and exercise psychology : potential contributions of a critical realist perspective Ryba, Tatiana V.; Wiltshire, Gareth; North, Julian; Ronkainen, Noora J. (Taylor & Francis, 2022)Notwithstanding diverse opinions and debates about mixing methods, mixed methods research (MMR) is increasingly being used in sport and exercise psychology. In this paper, we describe MMR trends within leading sport and ...
Siponen, Mikko; Klaavuniemi, Tuula (Springer, 2021)Generally, to publish a paper in a top IS journal, making a new theory contribution is, so we are told, required. Such a requirement also exists in Design Science Research (DSR) literature. We review a number of claims ...
Siponen, Mikko; Klaavuniemi, Tuula (Elsevier, 2020)The hypothetico-deductive (H-D) method is reported to be common in information systems (IS). In IS, the H-D method is often presented as a Popperian, Hempelian, or natural science method. However, there are many fundamental ...