Tensions and Paradoxes of Scaling Up : A Critical Reflection on Physical Activity Promotion
Koorts, H., Bauman, A., Edwards, N., Bellew, W., Brown, W. J., Duncan, M. J., Lubans, D. R., Milat, A. J., Morgan, P. J., Nathan, N., Searles, A., Lee, K., & Plotnikoff, R. C. (2022). Tensions and Paradoxes of Scaling Up : A Critical Reflection on Physical Activity Promotion. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(21), Article 14284. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph192114284
Authors
Date
2022Copyright
© 2022 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland.
Background: Achieving system-level, sustainable ‘scale-up’ of interventions is the epitome of successful translation of evidence-based approaches in population health. In physical activity promotion, few evidence-based interventions reach implementation at scale or become embedded within systems for sustainable health impact. This is despite the vast published literature describing efficacy studies of small-scale physical activity interventions. Research into physical activity scale-up (through case-study analysis; evaluations of scale-up processes in implementation trials; and mapping the processes, strategies, and principles for scale-up) has identified barriers and facilitators to intervention expansion. Many interventions are implemented at scale by governments but have not been evaluated or have unpublished evaluation information. Further, few public health interventions have evaluations that reveal the costs and benefits of scaled-up implementation. This lack of economic information introduces an additional element of risk for decision makers when deciding which physical activity interventions should be supported with scarce funding resources. Decision-makers face many other challenges when scaling interventions which do not relate to formal research trials of scale-up; Methods: To explore these issues, a multidisciplinary two-day workshop involving experts in physical activity scale-up was convened by the University of Newcastle, Australia, and the University of Ottawa, Canada (February 2019); Results: In this paper we discuss some of the scale-up tensions (challenges and conflicts) and paradoxes (things that are contrary to expectations) that emerged from this workshop in the context of the current literature and our own experiences in this field. We frame scale-up tensions according to epistemology, methodology, time, and partnerships; and paradoxes as ‘reach without scale’, ‘planned serendipity’ and ‘simple complexity’. We reflect on the implications of these scale-up tensions and paradoxes, providing considerations for future scale-up research and practice moving forward; Conclusions: In this paper, we delve deeper into stakeholders’ assumptions, processes and expectations of scaling up, and challenge in what ways as stakeholders, we all contribute to desired or undesired outcomes. Through a lens of ‘tensions’ and ‘paradoxes’, we make an original contribution to the scale-up literature that might influence current perspectives of scaling-up, provide future approaches for physical activity promotion, and contribute to understanding of dynamic of research-practice partnerships.
...
Publisher
MDPI AGISSN Search the Publication Forum
1661-7827Keywords
physical activity promotion scale-up implementation science interventions research scalability scalable interventions scale-up barriers scale-up facilitators health impact population health interventio laajentaminen sidosryhmät fyysinen aktiivisuus toimintaohjelmat poliittinen päätöksenteko kansanterveys terveyden edistäminen
Publication in research information system
https://converis.jyu.fi/converis/portal/detail/Publication/164384034
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
- Liikuntatieteiden tiedekunta [3077]
Additional information about funding
The physical activity scale-up workshop was funded by the University of Newcastle’s Priority Research Centre for Physical Activity and Nutrition, and the Canadian Institutes for Health Research (FRN 122510). D.R.L. is supported by an NHMRC Senior Research Fellowship (APP1154507). N.N. is supported by an NHMRC MRFF Investigator Grant (APP1194785). M.J.D. is supported by an NHMRC Career Development Fellowship (APP1141606). ...License
Related items
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
-
Scale-up of the Internet-based Professional Learning to help teachers promote Activity in Youth (iPLAY) intervention : a hybrid type 3 implementation-effectiveness trial
Lubans, D. R.; Sanders, T.; Noetel, M.; Parker, P.; McKay, H.; Morgan, P. J.; Salmon, J.; Kirwan, M.; Bennie, A.; Peralta, L.; Cinelli, R.; Moodie, M.; Hartwig, T.; Boyer, J.; Kennedy, S. G.; Plotnikoff, R. C.; Hansen, V.; Vasconcellos, D.; Lee, J.; Antczak, D.; Lonsdale, C. (Biomed Central, 2022)Background Whole-of-school programs have demonstrated success in improving student physical activity levels, but few have progressed beyond efficacy testing to implementation at-scale. The purpose of our study was to ... -
Effectiveness of Intervention Strategies to Increase Adolescents’ Physical Activity and Reduce Sedentary Time in Secondary School Settings, Including Factors Related to Implementation : A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Contardo Ayala, Ana María; Parker, Kate; Mazzoli, Emiliano; Lander, Natalie; Ridgers, Nicola D.; Timperio, Anna; Lubans, David R.; Abbott, Gavin; Koorts, Harriet; Salmon, Jo (Springer, 2024)Background Globally, just one in five adolescents meet physical activity guidelines and three-quarters of the school day is spent sitting. It is unclear which types of school-based interventions strategies increase physical ... -
A Web-Based Physical Activity Promotion Intervention for Inactive Parent-Child Dyads : Protocol for a Randomized Controlled Trial
Phipps, Daniel; Green, Weldon Thomas; Aho, Reetta; Kettunen, Eeva; Biddle, Stuart; Hamilton, Kyra; Laukkanen, Arto; Aunola, Kaisa; Chan, Derwin King; Hankonen, Nelli; Hassandra, Mary; Kärkkäinen, Tommi; Kykyri, Virpi-Liisa; Polet, Juho; Rhodes, Ryan; Ruiz, Montse C; Sääkslahti, Arja; Schneider, Jekaterina; Toivonen, Hanna-Mari; Lintunen, Taru; Hagger, Martin; Knittle, Keegan (JMIR Publications, 2024)Background: Low levels of physical activity are associated with numerous adverse health outcomes, yet sedentary lifestyles are common among both children and adults. Physical activity levels tend to decline steeply among ... -
Diverging paths in physical activity and sports participation (Health Promoting Sports Club, HPSC) cohort study: research data 2013-2023
Villberg, Jari; Kokko, Sami; Aira, Tuula (University of Jyväskylä, 2023)Liikkumisen ja urheilun erilaiset polut – Terveyttä edistävä liikuntaseura (TELS) on seurantatutkimus, jossa kartoitetaan eri suuntaisia (vähenevän, lisääntyvän ja ennallaan säilyvän) fyysisen aktiivisuuden ja liikuntase ... -
Rethinking children’s physical activity interventions at school : A new context-specific approach
Jago, Russell; Salway, Ruth; House, Danielle; Beets, Michael; Lubans, David Revalds; Woods, Catherine; de Vocht, Frank (Frontiers Media SA, 2023)Physical activity is important for children’s health. However, evidence suggests that many children and adults do not meet international physical activity recommendations. Current school-based interventions have had limited ...