Interpretation of gut microbiota data in the ‘eye of the beholder’ : A commentary and re‐evaluation of data from ‘Impacts of radiation exposure on the bacterial and fungal microbiome of small mammals in the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone’
Watts, P. C., Mappes, T., Tukalenko, E., Mousseau, T. A., Boratyński, Z., Møller, A. P., & Lavrinienko, A. (2022). Interpretation of gut microbiota data in the ‘eye of the beholder’ : A commentary and re‐evaluation of data from ‘Impacts of radiation exposure on the bacterial and fungal microbiome of small mammals in the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone’. Journal of Animal Ecology, 91(7), 1535-1545. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2656.13667
Published in
Journal of Animal EcologyAuthors
Date
2022Copyright
© 2022 the Authors
1. Evidence that exposure to environmental pollutants can alter the gut microbiota composition of wildlife includes studies of rodents exposed to radionuclides.
2. Antwis et al. (2021) used amplicon sequencing to characterise the gut microbiota of four species of rodent (Myodes glareolus, Apodemus agrarius, A. flavicollis and A. sylvaticus) inhabiting the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone (CEZ) to examine possible changes in gut bacteria (microbiota) and gut fungi (mycobiota) associated with exposure to radionuclides and whether the sample type (from caecum or faeces) affected the analysis.
3. The conclusions derived from the analyses of gut mycobiota are based on data that represent a mixture of ingested fungi (e.g. edible macrofungi, polypores, lichens and ectomycorrhizae) and gut mycobiota (e.g. microfungi and yeasts), which mask the patterns of inter- and intraspecific variation in the authentic gut mycobiota.
4. Implying that ‘faecal samples are not an accurate indicator of gut composition’ creates an unnecessary controversy about faecal sampling because the comparison of samples from the caecum and faeces confounds many other possible drivers (including different animals from different locations, sampled in different years) of variation in gut microbiota.
5. It is relevant also that Antwis et al.'s (2021) data lack statistical power to detect an effect of exposure to radionuclides on the gut microbiota because (1) all of their samples of Apodemus mice had experienced a medium or high total absorbed dose rate and (2) they did not collect samples of bank voles (M. glareolus) from replicate contaminated and uncontaminated locations.
6. Discussion of Antwis et al.'s (2021) analysis, especially the claims presented in the Abstract, is important to prevent controversy about the outcome of research on the biological impacts of wildlife inhabiting the CEZ.
...
Publisher
Wiley-BlackwellISSN Search the Publication Forum
0021-8790Keywords
Publication in research information system
https://converis.jyu.fi/converis/portal/detail/Publication/147102284
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
Related funder(s)
Research Council of FinlandFunding program(s)
Academy Project, AoFAdditional information about funding
Academy of Finland, Grant/Award Number: 287153, 324602, 268670 and 324604; Oskar Öflund Stiftelse; Samuel Freeman Charitable Trust; Scholarship Fund of the University of Oulu; University of Oulu Graduate School doctoral programmeLicense
Related items
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
-
The effect of chronic low-dose environmental radiation on organ mass of bank voles in the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone
Kivisaari, Kati; Boratyński, Zbyszek; Lavrinienko, Anton; Kesäniemi, Jenni; Lehmann, Philipp; Mappes, Tapio (Taylor & Francis, 2020)Purpose: Animals are exposed to environmental ionizing radiation (IR) externally through proximity to contaminated soil and internally through ingestion and inhalation of radionuclides. Internal organs can respond to ... -
Applying the Anna Karenina principle for wild animal gut microbiota : temporal stability of the bank vole gut microbiota in a disturbed environment
Lavrinienko, Anton; Tukalenko, Eugene; Kesäniemi, Jenni; Kivisaari, Kati; Masiuk, Sergii; Boratyński, Zbyszek; Mousseau, Timothy A.; Milinevsky, Gennadi; Mappes, Tapio; Watts, Phillip C. (John Wiley & Sons, 2020)Gut microbiota play an important role in host health. Yet, the drivers and patterns of microbiota imbalance (dysbiosis) in wild animals remain largely unexplored. One hypothesised outcome of stress on animal microbiomes ... -
Cities and their effects on free-living and host-associated microbes
Scholier, Tiffany (Jyväskylän yliopisto, 2023)Microbes are essential for all life on Earth and can be found in the environment or in association with host organisms, where they perform essential tasks either needed for the health of ecosystems or their hosts. Humans ... -
Defining gut mycobiota for wild animals : a need for caution in assigning authentic resident fungal taxa
Lavrinienko, Anton; Scholier, Tiffany; Bates, Scott T.; Miller, Andrew N.; Watts, Phillip C. (Biomed Central, 2021)Animal gut mycobiota, the community of fungi that reside within the gastrointestinal tract, make an important contribution to host health. Accordingly, there is an emerging interest to quantify the gut mycobiota of wild ... -
Skin and gut microbiomes of a wild mammal respond to different environmental cues
Lavrinienko, Anton; Tukalenko, Eugene; Mappes, Tapio; Watts, Phillip (BioMed Central, 2018)Background: Animal skin and gut microbiomes are important components of host fitness. However, the processes that shape the microbiomes of wildlife are poorly understood, particularly with regard to exposure to environmental ...