Experiences of arbitrary management among Finnish academics in an era of academic capitalism
Nikkola, T., & Tervasmäki, T. (2022). Experiences of arbitrary management among Finnish academics in an era of academic capitalism. Journal of Education Policy, 37(4), 548-568. https://doi.org/10.1080/02680939.2020.1854350
Published inJournal of Education Policy
© 2020 The Author(s). Published by InformaUK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
For the last two decades, Finnish universities have faced the implementation of new systems of control and undergone dramatic changes that have worsened academic working conditions – such as corporatisation and budget cuts. This article explores Finnish academics’ experiences of university reforms with a special focus on the consequences it has had in terms of organisational socio-dynamics. We adapt Glynos and Howarth’s logics of critical explanation and apply this theoretical framework to analyse the interviews of academics who, against their own will, did not have their contracts renewed. This approach describes, explains, and criticises the logics – which are social, political and fantasmatic – behind the existence, continuation, and transformation of practices that are very real. Our research findings suggest that there are situations in which experiences of opaque management may occur at university. Academics often found the decision-making processes to be unpredictable and ambiguous, leading to a precarious working atmosphere. Combining the logics approach with micro-level data analysis, we developed the concept of arbitrary management, offering new perspectives for understanding the mediation between social practices and structural reforms. This micro-political analysis provides a new take on how ideologies operate at university in an era of academic capitalism. ...
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Siekkinen, Taru; Pekkola, Elias; Kivistö, Jussi (Co-Action Publishing, 2016)Recruitment is a core instrument in the academic labour market. This article takes the perspective of the organisation here, the university on recruitment. Universities’ personnel policies and practises are shifting ...
Pekkola, Elias; Siekkinen, Taru; Kujala, Emmi-Niina; Kanniainen, Jari-Pekka; Laihonen, Harri (Taylor & Francis, 2021)This article maps the management actions that Finnish universities have taken during the COVID-19 pandemic and studies how managers in Finnish higher education coped during the crisis and how they feel about it. The article ...
Siekkinen, Taru; Pekkola, Elias; Carvalho, Teresa (Springer, 2020)The academic profession is challenged by the changing environment. Global trends, such as managerialism and new public management, have been influencing all public organizations, including universities. The academic ...
University-wide, top-down curriculum reform at a Finnish university : Perceptions of the academic staff Honkimäki, Sanna; Jääskelä, Päivikki; Kratochvil, Joachim; Tynjälä, Päivi (Routledge, 2022)This study examines academic staff’s perceptions of a university-wide, top-down curriculum reform in terms of the management of the reform, the support provided by the university’s administration, and the utilisation of ...
Feedback on individual academic presentations: exploring Finnish university students’ experiences and preferences Karoly, Adrienn (Research-publishing.net, 2015)With an increasing emphasis on measuring the outcomes of learning in higher education, assessment is gaining an ever more prominent role in curriculum design and development as well as in instructional practices. In ...