Negotiating digital surveillance legislation in post-Snowden times : An argumentation analysis of Finnish political discourse
Tiainen, M. K. (2019). Negotiating digital surveillance legislation in post-Snowden times : An argumentation analysis of Finnish political discourse. Journal of Language and Politics, 18 (2), 207-230. doi:10.1075/jlp.18004.tia
Published inJournal of Language and Politics
© John Benjamins Publishing Company
In the digital era, when security agencies world-wide have been challenging basic democratic principles with massive data gathering, Finland has had a different approach: it has conducted no large-scale surveillance of citizens’ online activities. Now, however, the country is planning such a vast expansion of state surveillance that the constitution itself must be altered. The present article examines one key point in this legislative process to see how the new surveillance measures are argued for and criticized, and how the differing points of view are negotiated to ultimately enable political action. Drawing particularly on Fairclough and Fairclough’s (2012) approach to argumentation in political discourse, the article finds that surveillance is promoted as essential for national security, and criticized especially for its economic risks, consequences for civil rights and questionable effectiveness. Despite this range of critical perspectives, only economic considerations become a topic of extended deliberation. ...
PublisherJohn Benjamins Publishing Co.
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
(De)legitimating electronic surveillance : a critical discourse analysis of the Finnish news coverage of the Edward Snowden revelations Tiainen, Minna Katriina (Routledge, 2017)In 2013, ex-National Security Agency (NSA) contractor Edward Snowden shocked the world by revealing the American NSA’s (and its partners’) extensive surveillance programs. The ensuing media discussion became a focal point ...
Helenius, Satu (2002)
“Red-haired teacher slain” : critical discourse analysis of news reportings in the case of Roseann Quinn Toivakka, Justiina (2020)Saamme suuren osa informaatiosta erilaisten uutisväylien kautta. Vaikka perinteisten sanomalehtien ja muiden vastaavien uutisjulkaisujen merkitys tiedonvälittäjinä on vähentynyt viime vuosina digitaalisten uutisten myötä, ...
Heroes or villains? : a critical discourse analysis of climate change discourses in logging-related editorials of Maaseudun Tulevaisuus Rautio, Sofia (2020)Metsät ovat olennainen osa ilmastonmuutoksen hillintää Suomessa, ja niiden hoitomenetelmät vaikuttavat suuresti hiilinielujen ja -varastojen laajuuteen. Suomen metsät ovat suurimmalta osin yksityisesti omistettuja, joten ...
‘It is important at this point to make clear that this study is not “anti-iPad”’ : Ed-Tech speak around iPads in educational technology research Mertala, Pekka (Routledge, 2021)This position paper contributes to the field of critical educational technology (Ed-Tech) research by providing empirical evidence for the qualities of the phenomenon known as Ed-Tech speak. The research question, how does ...