Trade-offs between ecosystem service provision and the predisposition to disturbances : a NFI-based scenario analysis
Temperli, C., Blattert, C., Stadelmann, G., Brändli, U.-B., & Thürig, E. (2020). Trade-offs between ecosystem service provision and the predisposition to disturbances : a NFI-based scenario analysis. Forest Ecosystems, 7, Article 27. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40663-020-00236-1
Published inForest Ecosystems
© The Author(s). 2020
Background Scenario analyses that evaluate management effects on the long-term provision and sustainability of forest ecosystem services and biodiversity (ESB) also need to account for disturbances. The objectives of this study were to reveal potential trade-offs and synergies between ESB provision and disturbance predisposition at the scale of a whole country. Methods The empirical scenario model MASSIMO was used to simulate forest development and management from years 2016 to 2106 on 5086 sample plots of the Swiss National Forest Inventory (NFI). We included a business-as-usual (BAU) scenario and four scenarios of increased timber harvesting. Model output was evaluated with indicators for 1) ESB provision including a) timber production, b) old-growth forest characteristics as biodiversity proxies and c) protection against rockfall and avalanches and 2) for a) storm and b) bark beetle predisposition. Results The predisposition indicators corresponded well (AUC: 0.71–0.86) to storm and insect (mostly bark beetle) damage observations in logistic regression models. Increased timber production was generally accompanied with decreased predisposition (storm: >−11%, beetle: >−37%, depending on region and scenario), except for a scenario that promoted conifers where beetle predisposition increased (e.g. + 61% in the Southern Alps). Decreased disturbance predisposition and decreases in old-growth forest indicators in scenarios of increased timber production revealed a trade-off situation. In contrast, growing stock increased under BAU management along with a reduction in conifer proportions, resulting in a reduction of beetle predisposition that in turn was accompanied by increasing old-growth forest indicators. Disturbance predisposition was elevated in NFI plots with high avalanche and rockfall protection value. Conclusions By evaluating ESB and disturbance predisposition based on single-tree data at a national scale we bridged a gap between detailed, stand-scale assessments and broader inventory-based approaches at the national scale. We discuss the limitations of the indicator framework and advocate for future amendments that include climate-sensitive forest development and disturbance modelling to strengthen decision making in national forest policy making. ...
ISSN Search the Publication Forum2095-6355
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Additional information about fundingThis research was funded as part of the Swiss NFI program by the Federal Office of Environment FOEN and the Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape research WSL.
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Sectoral policies cause incoherence in forest management and ecosystem service provisioning Blattert, Clemens; Eyvindson, Kyle; Hartikainen, Markus; Burgas, Daniel; Potterf, Maria; Lukkarinen, Jani; Snäll, Tord; Toraño-Caicoya, Astor; Mönkkönen, Mikko (Elsevier BV, 2022)Various national policies guide forest use, but often with competing policy objectives leading to divergent management paradigms. Incoherent policies may negatively impact the sustainable provision of forest ecosystem ...
A Multi-Criteria Decision Support System for Strategic Planning at the Swiss Forest Enterprise Level : Coping With Climate Change and Shifting Demands in Ecosystem Service Provisioning Thrippleton, Timothy; Blattert, Clemens; Bont, Leo Gallus; Mey, Reinhard; Zell, Jürgen; Thürig, Esther; Schweier, Janine (Frontiers Media SA, 2021)Sustainable forest management plays a key role for forest biodiversity and the provisioning of ecosystem services (BES), including the important service of carbon sequestration for climate change mitigation. Forest managers, ...
Mitigating forest biodiversity and ecosystem service losses in the era of bio-based economy Eyvindson, Kyle; Repo, Anna; Mönkkönen, Mikko (Elsevier, 2018)Forests play a crucial role in the transition towards a bioeconomy by providing biomass to substitute for fossil-based materials and energy. However, a policy-policy conflict exists between the desire to increase the ...
Changing forest stakeholders’ perception of ecosystem services with linguistic nudging Isoaho, K.; Burgas, D.; Janasik, N.; Mönkkönen, M.; Peura, M.; Hukkinen, J. I. (Elsevier BV, 2019)This paper explores whether the perceptions of forest owners and professionals could be nudged towards more sustainable management practices by adjusting a policy text’s metaphorical content. Recent research has demonstrated ...
Trade-offs among intensive forestry, ecosystem services and biodiversity in boreal forests Pohjanmies, Tähti (University of Jyväskylä, 2018)Finnish forests are used extensively for timber production but are also providers of other ecosystem services and harbor unique biodiversity. The ecosystem services approach has so far been used marginally in the context ...