(Dis)empowering assessment? : assessment as experienced by students in their upper secondary school EFL studies
Published inJyväskylä studies in humanities
Assessment has a great deal of power over students. However, there is little research on how students experience assessment and its power in the school context. The purpose of this mixed-methods study is therefore to examine how students in one Finnish upper secondary school experienced assessment and (dis)empowerment in their EFL studies. The present study, which situates itself within the realm of teacher research, also aims to experiment with alternative assessment methods in order to investigate whether they could foster empowerment in upper secondary EFL studies. The study comprises five articles and a monograph, and is divided into two parts, each with its own research aims. Part 1 and its three articles focus on students’ experiences of assessment and (dis)empowerment and explore what factors might predict disempowerment in assessment. In addition, Part 1 focuses on feedback as well as stress and test anxiety in connection with high-stakes testing as possible predictors of disempowerment. The data for these articles was gathered in March 2014 by means of a web-based questionnaire. The aim of Part 2 is to explore whether less traditional assessment methods could promote students’ empowerment in assessment. The first article in Part 2 focuses on cheat-sheet tests as a way of engaging and empowering students. The second article explores individual choice in corrective feedback. These teaching experiments took place in six upper secondary groups in 2013-2016. The third study in Part 2 is a monograph describing an earlier portfolio programme in EFL teaching. The present study shows that although most students were quite satisfied with the assessment in their EFL studies, a significant minority of students found the assessment disempowering. Several factors, such as inadequate or unhelpful feedback or stress and anxiety caused by assessment, predicted assessment disempowerment. However, students seemed to react to assessment as well as to these factors in a highly individual way. Furthermore, although the alternative assessment methods investigated in the teaching experiments proved useful and also empowering additions to the EFL assessment repertoire, students experienced them in different ways. There should therefore be a range of assessment methods to cater for different assessment purposes as well as for students’ different learning strategies, needs and personalities. ...
Alternative titleDisempowering assessment?
PublisherUniversity of Jyväskylä
MetadataShow full item record
- Väitöskirjat 
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Difficult but Valuable! Learning in Student-centered Assessment Feedback Practices in Higher Education Maunumäki, Minna; Maunula, Minna; Harju-Luukkainen, Heidi (Sciencedomain International, 2022)Aims: The aim of this study is to fill a gap in research on students' experiences of learning in student-centered assessment feedback practices. The article examines what students tell us about their learning in the context ...
Teachers and upper secondary school students' views on the role of teacher feedback in motivating Finnish EFL students to improve their written skills Vornanen, Katariina (2021)Opettajapalaute on merkittävä osa niin opettajien työtä kuin oppilaiden oppimisprosessia. Samalla tavalla myös oppilaiden motivaatio voi olla merkittävä tekijä oppimisen edistymisessä. Tässä tutkimuksessa kartoitetaan ...
Renko, Katariina (2012)Virheiden merkitys vieraiden kielten oppimisessa on tunnustettu aina 1970-luvulta lähtien, jolloin virheet alettiin nähdä välttämättömänä osana kielen ja sen sääntöjen oppimista. Virheiden tekemiseen vieraan kielen opiskelussa ...
Jokilehto, Emmi (2014)Englannin kielen asema maailmalla on muuttunut merkittävästi viime vuosikymmenten aikana ja se on saavuttanut vahvan aseman kansainvälisenä kielenä. Se toimii myös yhä enenevissä määrin maailmanlaajuisena lingua francana ...