Why open educational resources repositories fail : the contribution of quality approaches to the success of repositories
Published inJyväskylä studies in computing
Over the last two decades, millions of Open Educational Resources (OER) have become freely available for teachers and learners online. These resources are usually accessible through Learning Object Repositories (LORs), which are databases with a user interface. LORs are rarely used to their full potential and often considered as ‘failures’. Previous studies have shown that quality has a critical role in the success of information systems such as LORs. However there are no common guidelines for quality assurance approaches for LORs, nor are there studies into the contribution made by different LOR quality assurance approaches to the success of a repository. Measuring quality and success have proven to be a challenge in the research community due to the subjective and dynamic nature of such concepts. To meet this challenge, this thesis studied the perceptions of LOR users and developers with multiple methodological perspectives. The contribution of this thesis to academic discourse comes from its deepening of the understanding of LOR users’ and developers’ perceptions on the quality and success of repositories. Frameworks for LOR quality assurance approaches and LOR success metrics were developed in order to identify and design approaches that would augment LOR success, as a theoretical contribution. The findings of these studies show that expert reviews combined with user-generated quality approaches (e.g. recommendation systems, peer reviews, commenting, tagging etc.) contribute towards LOR success. The practical contribution of this thesis is a set of recommendations towards the design of LOR quality approaches. These recommendations have already been used as guidelines for creating quality assurance approaches for four major European LORs. ...
PublisherUniversity of Jyväskylä
- Article I:.Clements, K.I., Gras-Velazques, A. and Pawlowski, J.M (2011) Learning Object Repositories Challenging Google – Users Point of View, Published in the Proceedings of International Technology, Education and Development Conference (INTED 2011) Please see.
- Article II:Pawlowski, J.M. and Clements, K.I (2010) Implementing Quality Standards for Knowledge-Intensive Organizations, Published in Technology, Instruction, Cognition and Learning, Volume 7, Number 3-4, 2010 Please see.
- Article III:.Clements, K.I. and Pawlowski, J.M.(2012) User-oriented quality for OER: Understanding teachers’ views on re-use, quality and trust, Published in Journal of Computer Assisted Learning (JCAL) Vol-ume 28, Issue 1, pages 1-3, February 2012: DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2729.2011.00450.x
- Article IV:.Clements, K., Pawlowski, J. and Manouselis, N. (2015) Open Edu-cational Resources Repositories Literature Review – Towards a Comprehensive Quality Approaches Framework, Computers in Human Behavior Vol 51, Part B. October 2015. 2015 (Pages 1098-1106) Full text. DOI: 10.1016/j.chb.2015.03.026.
- Article V:.Clements, K., Pawlowski, J. and Manouselis, N. (2015) How do we measure OER Repositories Success? – a systematic literature review. Published in Proceedings of International Conference on Education and New Learning Technologies (EDULEARN2015) Please see
- Article VI:.Clements, K., Pawlowski, J. and Manouselis, N. (2014) Why Open Educational Resources Repositories Fail – Review of Quality As-surance Approaches. Published in Proceedings of International Conference on Education and New Learning Technologies (EDU-LEARN2014) Full text.
MetadataShow full item record
- Väitöskirjat 
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Clements, Kati; Pawlowski, Jan; Manouselis, Nikos (IATED Academy, 2014)Regardless of the amount of open educational resources (OER) available, many learning object repositories LORs fail to attract active users and sustainable funding solutions. Previous studies indicate that quality of OER ...
Stoffregen, Julia Dorothée (University of Jyväskylä, 2017)The use of Open Educational Resources (OERs) is promising as a complementary resource to traditional e-learning courses. Digital learning resources can be accessed on demand and can be developed by a wide range of ...
Explaining barriers to the usage of learning object repositories : comparison between Europe and Latin America Liao, Laidis Loriel (2020)Learning Object Repositories have a great potential to enhance knowledge sharing in the teaching community. However, the usage of Learning Object Repositories has not met the expectations that the supporting institutions ...
Open educational resources repositories literature review Towards a comprehensive quality approaches framework Clements, Kati; Pawlowski, Jan; Manouselis, Nikos (Pergamon, 2015)Today, Open Educational Resources (OER) are commonly stored, used, adapted, remixed and shared within Learning object repositories (LORs) which have recently started expanding their design to support collaborative teaching ...
Design Principles of Collaborative Learning Space Connecting Teachers and Refugee Children : A Design Science Research Study Nurhas, Irawan; Boutouil, Moussa; Geisler, Stefan; Pawlowski, Jan (IATED Academy, 2020)Learning the German language is one of the most critical challenges for refugee children in Germany. It is a prerequisite to allow communication and integration into the educational system. To solve the underlying problem, ...