Two traditions of cognitive sociology : an analysis and assessment of their cognitive and methodological assumptions
Kaidesoja, T., Hyyryläinen, M., & Puustinen, R. (2022). Two traditions of cognitive sociology : an analysis and assessment of their cognitive and methodological assumptions. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 52(3), 528-547. https://doi.org/10.1111/jtsb.12341
Published inJournal for the Theory of Social Behaviour
DisciplineKognitiotiedeKoulutusteknologia ja kognitiotiedeCognitive ScienceLearning and Cognitive Sciences
© 2022 the Authors
Cognitive sociology has been split into cultural and interdisciplinary traditions that position themselves differently in relation to the cognitive sciences and make incompatible assumptions about cognition. This article provides an analysis and assessment of the cognitive and methodological assumptions of these two traditions from the perspective of the mechanistic theory of explanation. We argue that while the cultural tradition of cognitive sociology has provided important descriptions about how human cognition varies across cultural groups and historical periods, it has not opened up the black box of cognitive mechanisms that produce and sustain this variation. This means that its explanations for the described phenomena have remained weak. By contrast, the interdisciplinary tradition of cognitive sociology has sought to integrate cognitive scientific concepts and methods into explanatory research on how culture influences action and how culture is stored in memory. Although we grant that interdisciplinary cognitive sociologists have brought many fresh ideas, concepts and methods to cultural sociology from the cognitive sciences, they have not always clarified their assumptions about cognition and their models have sketched only a few specific cognitive mechanisms through which culture influences action, meaning that they have not yet provided a comprehensive explanatory understanding of the interactions between culture, cognition and action. ...
ISSN Search the Publication Forum0021-8308
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Additional information about fundingThis study was funded by Koneen Säätiö and Emil Aaltosen Säätiö.
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Kognitiivinen sosiologia kulttuurin ja toiminnan suhteen tutkimuksessa Kaidesoja, Tuukka; Hyyryläinen, Mikko; Puustinen, Ronny; Heinonen, Matti (Westermarck-seura, 2021)Erilaiset kognitiota koskevat kysymyksenasettelut ovat viime vuosikymmeninä yleistyneet yhteiskuntatieteissä. Vaikka sosiologit eivät ole olleet tässä suhteessa edelläkävijöitä, sosiologian sisältä löytyy kuitenkin kasvava ...
Socio-emotional Experience in Human Technology Interaction Design : A Fashion Framework Proposal Rousi, Rebekah; Alanen, Hanna-Kaisa (Springer International Publishing, 2021)Technology designers and developers can be understood as social experience (SE) mediators. In user experience (UX), notions of SE have served to identify and define the factors contributing to human-technology interaction ...
Graffiti as a Palimpsest Myllylä, Mari (Street Art & Urban Creativity, 2018)Graffiti can be viewed as stories about embodied identities of the self and others which can be shared in intersubjective discourse, visual communication of varying content and motives, and utilizing specific technology ...
The socially distributed cognition of musical timbre : a convergence of semantic, perceptual, and acoustic aspects Ferrer, Rafael (University of Jyväskylä, 2012)
Climbing for equality: overcoming social inequality through sport : a narrative inquiry into the sport lives of five visually disabled climbers in Mexico City Castillo Negrete Eissa, Miguel Del (2016)This master thesis is a qualitative narrative inquiry that illustrates and explores the stories of five visually disabled participants who took up the practice of rock climbing and mountaineering as a means to overcome ...