“I feel many contradictory emotions” : Finnish mothers' discursive struggles with motherhood
Raudasoja, M., Sorkkila, M., Laitila, A., & Aunola, K. (2022). “I feel many contradictory emotions” : Finnish mothers' discursive struggles with motherhood. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 84(3), 752-772. https://doi.org/10.1111/jomf.12828
Published inJournal of Marriage and the Family
© 2022 the Authors
Objective The aim of the study was to facilitate the understanding and interpretation of multiple aspects of working with mothers by examining Finnish mothers' mothering discourses and the interplay among these discourses. Background According to relational dialectics theory, discourses are systems of meaning that are coproduced in interaction. Although discursive research on motherhood has identified various discourses, research on the interplay among competing motherhood discourses is in its infancy. Method Qualitative questionnaire data from 479 Finnish mothers of infants were analyzed using contrapuntal analysis. Mothers' responses to three open-ended questions were analyzed inductively. Emerging themes were identified so as to represent different motherhood discourses, and the power struggle among discourses was addressed. Results Four discourses were identified. In the Equality discourse, parenting was presented as ideally shared between co-parents, and equality between family members and various family forms was promoted. In the Familistic discourse, traditional stay-at-home mothering, good housekeeping, and the unity of the family were emphasized. In the Intensive Mothering discourse, the importance of the mother to her child was highlighted. In the Balance discourse, the needs of all family members were presented as equally important, and flexibility in parenting choices was promoted. The results demonstrated discursive struggles within mothers' answers, suggesting that contemporary Finnish motherhood is a contested terrain of competing ideologies. Conclusion The findings suggest that Finnish mothers' mothering discourses are multivocal and often competing. The results contribute to the current understanding of motherhood ideologies and provide new insights to be utilized in counseling and clinical practice. ...
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Related funder(s)Alli Paasikivi Foundation
Additional information about fundingAlli Paasikiven Säätiö, Grant/Award Number:21000041571
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Mikkonen, Kristiina; Veikkola, Henna-Riikka; Sorkkila, Matilda; Aunola, Kaisa (Springer, 2022)In the present study, we examined what kind of parenting style groups (defined by parental warmth, behavioral control, and psychological control) can be identified among contemporary Finnish mothers and fathers and how ...
Ranta, Minna; Böök, Marja Leena; Paloniemi, Susanna; Rönkä, Anna (Routledge, Taylor & Francis, 2023)This study examined the expectations of expectant first-time parents on coparenting in a Finnish two-parent family. Thirty expectant couples were individually interviewed (N = 60) during the third trimester of pregnancy. ...
Krysa, Isabella; Kivijärvi, Marke (Emerald, 2022)Purpose This research attempts to make sense of the experiences of two academic women who become mothers. Design/methodology/approach This paper is an autoethnography. Applying the autoethnographic method allows ...
Lin, Gao-Xian; Mikolajczak, Moïra; Keller, Heidi; Akgun, Ege; Arikan, Gizem; Aunola, Kaisa; Barham, Elizabeth; Besson, Eliane; Blanchard, M. Annelise; Boujut, Emilie; Brianda, Maria Elena; Brytek-Matera, Anna; César, Filipa; Chen, Bin-Bin; Dorard, Géraldine; dos Santos, Elias Luciana Carla; Dunsmuir, Sandra; Egorova, Natalia; Escobar, Maria Josefina; Favez, Nicolas; Fontaine, Anne Marie; Foran, Heather; Furutani, Kaichiro; Gannagé, Myrna; Gaspar, Maria; Godbout, Lucie; Goldenberg, Amit; Gross, James J.; Gurza, Maria Ancuta; Hatta, Ogma; Heeren, Alexandre; Helmy, Mai; Huynh, Mai-Trang; Kaneza, Emérence; Kawamoto, Taishi; Kellou, Nassima; Kpassagou, Bassantéa Lodegaèna; Lazarevic, Ljiljana; Le Vigouroux, Sarah; Lebert-Charron, Astrid; Leme, Vanessa; MacCann, Carolyn; Manrique-Millones, Denisse; Medjahdi, Oussama; Millones Rivalles, Rosa Bertha; Miranda Orrego, María Isabel; Miscioscia, Marina; Mousavi, Seyyedeh Fatemeh; Moutassem-Mimouni, Badra; Murphy, Hugh; Ndayizigiye, Alexis; Ngnombouowo, Tenkue Josué; Olderbak, Sally; Ornawka, Sophie; Cádiz, Daniela Oyarce; Pérez-Díaz, Pablo A.; Petrides, Konstantinos; Prikhidko, Alena; Salinas-Quiroz, Fernando; Santelices, Maria-Pia; Schrooyen, Charlotte; Silva, Paola; Simonelli, Alessandra; Sorkkila, Matilda; Stănculescu, Elena; Starchenkova, Elena; Szczygieł, Dorota; Tapia, Javier; Tremblay, Melissa; Tri, Thi Minh Thuy; Üstündağ-Budak, A. Meltem; Valdés, Pacheco Maday; van Bakel, Hedwig; Verhofstadt, Lesley; Wendland, Jaqueline; Yotanyamaneewong, Saengduean; Roskam, Isabelle (Sage Publications, 2023)What is it to be “an ideal parent”? Does the answer differ across countries and social classes? To answer these questions in a way that minimizes bias and ethnocentrism, we used open-ended questions to explore ideal-parent ...
Mustosmäki, Armi (Kulttuurintutkimuksen seura, 2023)