Avicenna on Negative Judgement
Kaukua, J. (2020). Avicenna on Negative Judgement. Topoi: An International Review of Philosophy, 39(3), 657-666. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-016-9380-5
Published inTopoi: An International Review of Philosophy
© 2020 Springer
Avicenna’s logical theory of negative judgement can be seen as a systematic development of the insights Aristotle had laid out in the De interpretatione. However, in order to grasp the full extent of his theory one must extend the examination from the logical works to the metaphysical and psychological bases of negative judgement. Avicenna himself often refrains from the explicit treatment of the connections between logic and metaphysics or psychology, or treats them in a rather oblique fashion. Time and again he is satisfied with noting that this or that question is not proper for a logician and should be dealt with in metaphysics or psychology—without bothering to refer his reader to the exact loci. The following is an attempt at a reconstruction of Avicenna’s theory of negative judgement in such a broad fashion. I will begin with his analysis of negative judgement as resulting from an operation of ‘removing’ the predicate term from the subject term. On this basis, I will move on to discuss how he conceives of the relation between negative judgements and affirmative judgements that contain privative or metathetic terms as well as the question of whether negative judgements can be reduced to affirmative ones. Having thus laid out his logical theory of negation, I move on to discuss the underlying metaphysics by looking at the relation between existence and non-existence, and existence and privation. Finally, I will address Avicenna’s scattered psychological remarks on how we can conceive of what does not exist. ...
ISSN Search the Publication Forum0167-7411
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Related funder(s)Academy of Finland
Funding program(s)Academy Research Fellow, AoF; Research costs of Academy Research Fellow, AoF
Additional information about fundingThe research has been funded by the Academy of Finland.
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Book Review : Damien Janos. Avicenna on the Ontology of Pure Quiddity Kaukua, Jari (İlmi Etüdler Derneği, 2022)
The Influence of the Avicennan Theory of Science on Philosophical Sufism : The Concept of the Divine Science in Qūnawī and Fanārī Daşdemir, Yusuf (Brill, 2020)This article discusses the application of the Avicennan theory of demonstrative science on taṣawwuf, or the Divine Science (al-ʿilm al-ilāhī), by members of the Akbarian tradition, particularly Ibn ʿArabī’s (d. 1240) stepson ...
Clearing the Soul for Paradise – Taslīk al-nafs ilā ḥaẓīrat al-quds al-Allāma al-Ḥillī; Kaukua, Jari (AMI Press, 2021)Clearing the Soul for Paradise (Taslīk al-nafs ilā ḥaẓīrat al-quds) is a concise but comprehensive summa of theology, which al-ʿAllāma al-Ḥillī composed for his son at a midpoint of his career. It addresses all fields of ...
Iʿtibārī Concepts in Suhrawardī : The Case of Substance Kaukua, Jari (Brill, 2020)Shihāb al-Dīn al-Suhrawardī (d. 587/1191) famously criticised the central concepts of Avicennian metaphysics as merely mind-dependent (or iʿtibārī) notions. This paper aims to show that despite his critique, Suhrawardī ...
"Not So Ridiculous" : Avicenna on the Existence of Nature (tabi'a) contra Aristotle and the Ash'arites Dadikhuda, Davlat (Oxford University Press, 2019)In this paper, I set out to explicate what I take to be a distinctive argument that Avicenna offers for the existence of nature (ṭabī ͑a) as a causal power (quwwa) in bodies (ajsām). In doing this, I first clarify the ...