Intervention Effect Rates as a Path to Research Relevance : Information Systems Security Example
Siponen, M., & Baskerville, R. L. (2018). Intervention Effect Rates as a Path to Research Relevance : Information Systems Security Example. Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 19(4), Article 4. https://doi.org/10.17705/1jais.00491
Published inJournal of the Association for Information Systems
© the Authors & Association for Information Systems, 2018.
In the current information systems security (ISS) research, new theory contributions are especially valued. This research typically reflects the following formula: Suggest a new theory (or set of constructs) of ISS and show that it is empirically supported, then suggest another new theory (or set of constructs with some linkages) and show that it is empirically supported, and so on. Despite the merits of this approach, it leaves out many important scientific aspects. For example, after more than 30 years of ISS research, (1) we know little about the conditions and situations to which new theories (or constructs) do not apply; (2) we do not know which new theories are more effective than others in solving an ISS problem; and (3) we have not demonstrated that our best research, or new theoretical contributions, can beat industry best practices or practitioners’ intuitive approaches. We suggest that ISS research be examined in terms of long-term research programs comprising four levels: metalevel research, basic research, applied research, and postintervention research. The ultimate success of such programs does not entail new theories, “contextualized theories,” or adding IT artifacts to theories; rather, it hinges on the question of which program can demonstrate the best intervention effect rate for a given ISS problem. The lack of demonstrated intervention effectiveness (e.g., by showing treatment effect rates) is one important inhibitor that may prevent ISS research from achieving relevance in practice. Without reporting such evidence, ISS research cannot overpower the folklore, fads, or industry “best practices” that often guide operations. With such treatment effect rates, evidence-based practice may become more justifiable. We believe that our ideas also can be applied to information systems research in general. ...
PublisherAssociation for Information Systems
ISSN Search the Publication Forum1536-9323
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
On research work in information systems: Guidelines, recommendations and examples Järvinen, Pertti (2021)The most positive aspect of science is that the participants (researchers, reviewers and editors) control and evaluate their work themselves. Therefore they must be supported in one way or another. Fortunately, guidelines ...
Common Misunderstandings of Deterrence Theory in Information Systems Research and Future Research Directions Siponen, Mikko; Soliman, Wael; Vance, Anthony (ACM, 2022)In the 1980s, information systems (IS) borrowed deterrence theory (DT) from the field of criminology to explain information security behaviors (or intention). Today, DT is among the most commonly used theories in IS security ...
Reconsidering the Role of Research Method Guidelines for Qualitative, Mixed-methods, and Design Science Research Holtkamp, Philipp; Soliman, Wael; Siponen, Mikko (University of Hawai'i at Manoa, 2019)Guidelines for different qualitative research genres have been proposed in information systems (IS). As these guidelines are outlined for conducting and evaluating good research, studies may be denied publication ...
Client information systems’ support for case-based social work : experiences of Finnish social workers Salovaara, Samuel; Ylönen, Katri (Routledge, 2022)In recent years, Finland has seen extensive development in the area of social and healthcare information management aimed at harmonizing client information systems (CISs) and ways of documenting client information. The ...
Social welfare professionals willing to participate in client information system development : Results from a large cross-sectional survey Martikainen, Susanna; Salovaara, Samuel; Ylönen, Katri; Tynkkynen, Elina; Viitanen, Johanna; Tyllinen, Mari; Lääveri, Tinja (Taylor & Francis, 2022)Human-centered design methods should be implemented throughout the client information system (CIS) development process to understand social welfare professionals’ needs, tasks, and contexts of use. The aim of this study ...