Measuring Distraction at the Levels of Tactical and Strategic Control: The Limits of Capacity-Based Measures for Revealing Unsafe Visual Sampling Models
Published inAdvances in Human-Computer Interaction
Copyright © 2011 Tuomo Kujala and Pertti Saariluoma. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
The control theory of driving suggests that driver distraction can be analyzed as a breakdown of control at three levels. Common approach for analyzing distraction experimentally is to utilize capacity-based measures to assess distraction at the level of operational control. Three driving simulation experiments with 61 participants were organized to evaluate which kind of measures could be used to analyze drivers' tactical visual sampling models and the related effects of distraction while searching textual information on in-car display. The effects of two different text types were evaluated. The utilized capacity-based measures seemed to be insufficient for revealing participants' tactical behaviors or effects of text type. The measures of workload or performance did not indicate reliably the differences found between participants' visual sampling strategies or which text type is better for enabling safer task timing behaviors. Visual sampling measures did indicate effects of text type on participants' tactical abilities. Differences in participants' visual sampling strategies leading to different levels of systematicity in visual behaviors can explain the variances in visual sampling efficiency. Displays encouraging unsystematic glance allocation behaviors were found potentially the most distracting in relation to safe visual sampling of in-vehicle displays. ...
PublisherHindawi Publishing Corporation
ajonaikaiset häiriötekijät ajoneuvotietojärjestelmät ohjaustasot operationaalinen taso taktinen taso strateginen taso keskeytetty visuaalinen tiedonhaku mentaaliset representaatiot driver distraction in-vehicle information systems levels of control operational control tactical control strategic control interrupted visual search visual sampling mental representations
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Browsing the information highway while driving: three in-vehicle touch screen scrolling methods and driver distraction Kujala, Tuomo (Springer, 2013)Distraction effects of three alternative touch screen scrolling methods for searching music tracks on a mobile device were studied in a driving simulation experiment with 24 participants. Page-bypage scrolling methods ...
Effects of menu structure and touch screen scrolling style on the variability of glance durations during in-vehicle visual search tasks Kujala, Tuomo; Saariluoma, Pertti (Taylor & Francis, 2011)The effects of alternative navigation device display features on drivers' visual sampling efficiency while searching forpoints of interest were studied in two driving simulation experiments with 40 participants. Given that ...
Impacts of Touch Screen Size, User Interface Design, and Subtask Boundaries on In-Car Task's Visual Demand and Driver Distraction Grahn, Hilkka; Kujala, Tuomo (Elsevier, 2020)Visual distraction by secondary in-car tasks is a major contributing factor in traffic incidents. In-car user interface design may mitigate these negative effects but to accomplish this, design factors’ visual distraction ...
Nurminen, Miika; Heimbürger, Anneli (Tallinn University of Technology, 2011)
Nurminen, Miika; Heimbürger, Anneli (IOS Press, 2012)An implementation-oriented model to represent uncertain temporal information in databases is proposed. Temporal information is presented to the user as anchored time intervals with optional beginning and end dates. The ...