Taking the Language of the Past Seriously: The Linguistic Turns in Finnish and Swedish History Dissertations, 1970-2010
Julkaistu sarjassa
JYU dissertationsTekijät
Päivämäärä
2019Tekijänoikeudet
© The Author & University of Jyväskylä
The linguistic turn in historical research has shifted the interest of an increasing
number of historians into problematizing the nature of past language. In this
study the linguistic turn has been divided into five different approaches—
conceptual history, linguistic contextualism, discursivity, linguistically
constructed gender, and narrativity. This categorization is based on the senior
theorists R. Koselleck, Q. Skinner, M. Foucault, J. Scott, and H. White, and the
first wave of linguistic turns their works impacted within historical studies. Thus,
these linguistic turns have foreign background and they have been gradually
imported into Finland and Sweden. It is an interplay between local historical
traditions and foreign scholarly adaptions. By analyzing doctoral dissertations of
history defended in Sweden and Finland in 1970–2010, and the reviews of them,
similarities but also differences are seen between ways to conduct historical
research in these countries. Less than 10 percent of the dissertations in both
countries included references to linguistic turns: in the Finnish case circa 9% and
in the Swedish case 6%. Linguistic turns themselves have become diversified,
both in international and national debates. Their impact on Finnish and Swedish
historiography has been notable, but not comprehensive. The role and essence of
language has been acknowledged more widely and deeply during the last few
decades, but the applications of linguistically oriented approaches remain within
a limited number of scholars. The pace of adopting and elaborating linguistic
turns tells also about the historiography of these countries more widely. In
Finland, the discipline of general history (yleinen historia) has a long tradition of
being internationally oriented, and the applications of linguistically oriented
methods validates this fact. In turn, the discipline of the history of ideas and
science (idé- och lärdomshistoria) in Sweden has created links between their
methodological starting points and linguistic contextualism or conceptual
history. Historians from both countries have contributed to linguistically
oriented methods with their local and national applications, but the pace and
coverage has been quicker and more extensive in Finland. This reflects openness
to international debates in a smaller nation state.
Keywords: Historiography, Linguistic Turn, Methodology, Reception, Finland
and Sweden, Dissertations, Comparative History, 1970–2010
...
Julkaisija
Jyväskylän yliopistoISBN
978-951-39-7991-1ISSN Hae Julkaisufoorumista
2489-9003Asiasanat
1970-luku 1980-luku 1990-luku 2000-2009 2010 historia historiankirjoitus käsitehistoria aatehistoria historiankäsitys historiantutkimus genretutkimus kielitiede kieli ja kielet kontekstuaalisuus diskurssi narratiivisuus väitöskirjat Suomi Ruotsi historiography linguistic turn methodology reception Finland and Sweden dissertations comparative history
Metadata
Näytä kaikki kuvailutiedotKokoelmat
- JYU Dissertations [836]
- Väitöskirjat [3535]
Lisenssi
Samankaltainen aineisto
Näytetään aineistoja, joilla on samankaltainen nimeke tai asiasanat.
-
Early modern Swedish state-building in Swedish and Finnish historiography
Räihä, Antti (Routledge, 2024)This chapter contributes to a historiographical debate concerning early modern Swedish state-building that has raged in Sweden and Finland for decades. It seems today that historians are in general agreement that the ... -
Integrating a Nexus : the History of Political Discourse and Language Policy Research
Ihalainen, Pasi; Saarinen, Taina (Routledge, 2019)Historians of political discourse and language policy researchers should join forces to develop methods of textual analysis that help to integrate political and intellectual history. They could do so by focusing their ... -
A Qualitative and Quantitative Study on Ancient Latin Texts Concerning the Concept of aether : Some Methodological Considerations
Roschier, Henrik (Jyväskylän yliopisto, 2022)My study focuses on the semantic analysis of an ambiguous Latin word, aether, which may roughly be translated as ‘celestial substance’. The study is carried out by utilising both qualitative and quantitative methods on a ... -
The rise and fall of the Swedish Empire : causes and explanations
Karonen, Petri (Routledge, 2024)This chapter analyzes the explanations offered by historians at different times for the rise and fall of Sweden as a great power. There is no consensus even on when Sweden’s great power status actually began or ended. ... -
People & Parliament: A Comparative Interface on Parliamentary Debates in Northwest Europe since the Nineteenth Century
Ihalainen, Pasi; Vaara, Ville; Bonin, Hugo; Turunen, Risto; Janssen, Berit; Marjanen, Jani; Van der Plas, Luka; Van Stiphout, Mees (University of Jyväskylä, 2024)Vertaileva käyttöliittymä parlamentaarisen keskustelun tutkimiseen. Käsittää tällä hetkellä täysistuntokeskustelut Britannian (1803-2021), Ruotsin (1809-2022), Alankomaat (1814-), Norjan (1814-2016), Tanskan (1849-2016), ...
Ellei toisin mainittu, julkisesti saatavilla olevia JYX-metatietoja (poislukien tiivistelmät) saa vapaasti uudelleenkäyttää CC0-lisenssillä.