Can manipulation of ungulate herbivory facilitate biodiversity conservation for forest vegetation and invertebrates?
Macdonald, E., Löhmus, A., Bernes, C., Junninen, K., Macura, B., Müller, J., Sandström, J. and Jonsson, B. G. (2018). Can manipulation of ungulate herbivory facilitate biodiversity conservation for forest vegetation and invertebrates?. 5th European Congress of Conservation Biology. doi: 10.17011/conference/eccb2018/107555
© the Authors, 2018
Livestock grazing and ‘overabundance’ of large wild herbivores in forests have long been perceived as conflicting with the aims of both silviculture and forest conservation; however, herbivory can also help to maintain certain forest habitat values. Management of mammalian herbivory in protected forests can, therefore, be an important tool for biodiversity conservation and restoration. We conducted a full systematic review with meta-analyses to examine how manipulation of the grazing/browsing pressure affects forest vegetation and invertebrates. Our systematic review included studies of experimental manipulation of ungulate herbivory in boreal and temperate forests. Non-intervention or alternative levels of intervention were used as comparators. Relevant outcomes included abundance, diversity and composition of plants and invertebrates, tree regeneration, and performance of target species. 144 studies were included in the review, most from a recent systematic map (1) but with updates based on searches online and bibliographies of existing reviews. Most studies had been conducted in North America, Europe or Australia/New Zealand. The intervention most commonly studied was experimental exclusion (or enclosure) of wild and/or domestic ungulates by fencing. Other studies examined culling of wild ungulates or compared forests grazed by livestock to ungrazed forests. We found negative effects of herbivory on the abundance (cover) of understorey vegetation as a whole, woody understorey and bryophytes, and also on the species richness of woody understorey vegetation. In contrast, herbivory had a positive effect on the richness of forbs and bryophytes. Ungulate origin was a significant effect modifier: Understorey abundance responded negatively to livestock and to ungulates introduced into the wild, but not to native ones. In contrast, understorey species richness responded positively to livestock but not to wild ungulates. The effects on woody understorey abundance and richness became increasingly negative with increasing duration and intensity of herbivory, respectively. Despite a paucity of studies reporting on invertebrates we detected a significant negative effect of herbivory on lepidopteran and spider abundance, but not richness. Our review confirmed that, if used carefully, manipulation of ungulate herbivory can be an effective tool for the management of tree regeneration, understorey vegetation or certain invertebrate groups. Important knowledge gaps included few studies of: boreal areas, long-term herbivory effects, impacts on bryophytes, lichens and invertebrates, and effects of manipulation less radical than total exclusion of ungulates. 1Bernes, C., B.G. Jonsson, K. Junninen, A. Lõhmus, S.E. Macdonald, J. Müller, J. Sandström. 2015. What is the impact of active management on biodiversity in boreal and temperate forests set aside for conservation or restoration? A systematic map. Environmental Evidence 4:25 DOI 10.1186/s13750-015-0050-7 ...
PublisherOpen Science Centre, University of Jyväskylä
ConferenceECCB2018: 5th European Congress of Conservation Biology. 12th - 15th of June 2018, Jyväskylä, Finland
MetadataShow full item record
- ECCB 2018 
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Sandström, Jennie; Bernes, Claes; Junninen, Kaisa; Löhmus, Asko; Macdonald, Ellen; Müller, Jörg; Jonsson, Bengt-Gunnar (Open Science Centre, University of Jyväskylä, 2018)Dead wood (DW) provides a critical habitat for thousands of wood-dependent (saproxylic) species in forests. However, intensification of forest management has heavily reduced the amount and diversity of DW. This has resulted ...
The three-toed woodpecker: an important biodiversity indicator and model species for the conservation of biodiversity in boreal forests. Versluijs, Martijn; Roberge, Jean-Michel (Open Science Centre, University of Jyväskylä, 2018)The use of biodiversity indicators have been proposed as a comprehensive method for assessing conservation values at the stand scale. In the boreal biome, the three-toed woodpecker have been proposed as an indicator for ...
On effective biodiversity conservation, sustainability of bioeconomy, and honesty of the Finnish forest policy Kotiaho, Janne Sakari (Finnish Zoological and Botanical Publishing Board, 2017)
Landscape level conservation needs more than a plan: understanding conditions for forest biodiversity governance Primmer, Eeva (Open Science Centre, University of Jyväskylä, 2018)Despite the introductory and concluding remarks in most conservation papers and funding applications, the main bottleneck for applying knowledge towards effective conservation is not our understanding of forest structures ...
Hjältén, Joakim; Hägglund, Ruaridh; Lövroth, Therese; Roberge, Jean-Michel; Olsson, Jörgen; Bell, David; Nilsson, Christer; Jørgensen, Dolly; Dynesius, Mats (Open Science Centre, University of Jyväskylä, 2018)Forest restoration for biodiversity conservation: some case studies from Sweden Because of worldwide forest degradation, eroding biodiversity and ecosystem services, ecological restoration has become a global priority. ...