‘Democracy’ and ‘People’s Power’ in the Finnish Parliament : the Struggle between Representative, Participatory and Direct Democracy
Hyvärinen, M., Kurunmäki, J., Turunen, R., Teräs, K., Andrushchenko, M., & Peltonen, J. (2023). ‘Democracy’ and ‘People’s Power’ in the Finnish Parliament : the Struggle between Representative, Participatory and Direct Democracy. Redescriptions, 26(2), 117-140. https://doi.org/10.33134/rds.410
Published in
RedescriptionsAuthors
Date
2023Copyright
© 2023 The Author(s)
The Finnish language is one that offers two translations of the concept ‘democracy,’ demokratia and kansanvalta (people’s power), which have remained in active political use. We analyse the existence of two terms as a linguistic affordance, providing political agents with possibilities for resisting and supporting the prevailing interpretations of democracy. We ask how and where the different versions occur in parliamentary speech (1980–2021) and in the MPs’ interviews (1998–2018). In quantitative analysis, we study the relative appearance of words close to these terms. In qualitative analysis, we study such terms (e.g. representative, Finnish and western) that have different profiles with demokratia and kansanvalta and study how these terms characterise and shape democracy. This way, we are able to question the dictionary-based understanding of these terms as synonyms. The difference between them is both geographical, kansanvalta referring more strictly to domestic phenomena, and functional, since demokratia covers most of the issues of procedural democracy and kansanvalta more distinctively the realisation of the presumed will of the people.
...
Publisher
Helsingin yliopistoISSN Search the Publication Forum
2308-0914Keywords
Publication in research information system
https://converis.jyu.fi/converis/portal/detail/Publication/197276389
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
Related funder(s)
Research Council of FinlandFunding program(s)
Research costs of Academy Professor, AoFAdditional information about funding
The research work for this article was funded by the Academy of Finland research projects ‘Voices of democracy’ (308792) and ‘Political temporalities’ (348744).License
Related items
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
-
Importable or exceptional? Swiss direct-democratic instruments in the French and German Parliaments, 2000–19
Bonin, Hugo; Kergomard, Zoé; Ihalainen, Pasi; Herrmann, Irène (Taylor & Francis, 2024)Recent years have seen growing interest in the ways politicians conceive direct democracy instruments (DDIs) and their integration into representative systems as one way to increase citizen participation. Our investigation ... -
Debating right to asylum : a conceptual and rhetorical reading of the German post-war deliberations
Kivistö, Hanna-Mari (University of Jyväskylä, 2013) -
Representative Democracy as a Contested Concept : Parliaments after the French, Russian and Digital Revolutions
Ihalainen, Pasi (University of Vienna, 2023)Democracy is a highly contested and historically elastic concept. The analysis of its changing meanings benefits from comparisons over time and beyond national histories, nowadays supported by digital history. In this ... -
Building and Testing a Comparative Interface on Northwest European Historical Parliamentary Debates : Relative Term Frequency Analysis of British Representative Democracy
Ihalainen, Pasi; Janssen, Berit; Marjanen, Jani; Vaara, Ville (RWTH Aachen, 2022)Tensions between the people and parliament over representation are a normal feature of representative democracies. In this paper, we demonstrate how digital humanities analysis tools help in answering questions about the ... -
Speaking of politics in parliament : experiences of writing a book on the digitized Bundestag debates, 1949–2017
Palonen, Kari (Routledge, 2022)This article consists of ex post methodological reflections on the procedures and practices that I applied in my monograph Politik als parlamentarischer Begriff: Perspektiven aus den Plenardebatten des Deutschen Bundestags ...