Sensitivity of bipartite network analyses to incomplete sampling and taxonomic uncertainty
Llopis‐Belenguer, C., Balbuena, J. A., Blasco‐Costa, I., Karvonen, A., Sarabeev, V., & Jokela, J. (2023). Sensitivity of bipartite network analyses to incomplete sampling and taxonomic uncertainty. Ecology, 104(4), Article e3974. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecy.3974
Published in
EcologyAuthors
Date
2023Copyright
© 2023 The Authors. Ecology published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of The Ecological Society of America.
Bipartite network analysis is a powerful tool to study the processes structuring interactions in ecological communities. In applying the method, it is assumed that the sampled interactions provide an accurate representation of the actual community. However, acquiring a representative sample may be difficult as not all species are equally abundant or easily identifiable. Two potential sampling issues can compromise the conclusions of bipartite network analyses: failure to capture the full range of interactions (sampling completeness) and use of a taxonomic level higher than species to evaluate the network (taxonomic resolution). We asked how commonly used descriptors of bipartite antagonistic communities (modularity, nestedness, connectance and specialisation (H2’)) are affected by reduced host sampling completeness, parasite taxonomic resolution and their crossed effect, since they are likely to co-occur. We used a quantitative niche model to generate weighted bipartite networks that resembled natural host-parasite communities. The descriptors were more sensitive to uncertainty in parasite taxonomic resolution than to host sampling completeness. When only 10% of parasite taxonomic resolution was retained, modularity and specialisation decreased ~76% and ~12% respectively, and nestedness and connectance increased ~114% and ~345% respectively. The loss of taxonomic resolution led to a wide range of possible communities, which makes it difficult to predict its effects on a given network. With regards to host sampling completeness, standardised nestedness, connectance and specialisation were robust, whereas modularity was sensitive (~30% decrease). The combination of both sampling issues had an additive effect on modularity. In communities with low effort for both sampling issues (50-10% of sampling completeness and taxonomic resolution), estimators of modularity and nestedness could not be distinguished from those of random assemblages. Thus, the categorical description of communities with low sampling effort (e.g., if a community is modular or not) should be done with caution. We recommend evaluating both sampling completeness and taxonomic certainty when conducting bipartite network analyses. Care should also be exercised when using non-robust descriptors (the four descriptors for parasite taxonomic resolution; modularity for host sampling completeness) when sampling issues are likely to affect a dataset.
...
Publisher
John Wiley & SonsISSN Search the Publication Forum
0012-9658Keywords
Publication in research information system
https://converis.jyu.fi/converis/portal/detail/Publication/176466375
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
Additional information about funding
We thank Dr S. Dennis (EAWAG) for his computation assistance. CLB acknowledges the support of an ETH Postdoctoral Fellowship (20-2 FEL-67). VS thanks the support from the Slovakian Government for Excellent Researchers Threatened by the War Conflict in Ukraine (09I03-03-V01-00017). IBC acknowledges the funding from the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF grant 31003A_169211)License
Related items
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
-
Parasite transmission in aquatic ecosystems under temperature change : effects of host activity and elimination of parasite larvae by filter-feeders
Gopko, Misha; Mironova, Ekaterina; Pasternak, Anna; Mikheev, Victor; Taskinen, Jouni (Wiley-Blackwell, 2020)A moderate raise in temperature was suggested to enhance the impact of parasites on aquatic ecosystems. Under higher temperatures, poikilothermic animals (e.g. fish) increase their activity, which can result in a more ... -
Spatiotemporal and gender-specific parasitism in two species of gobiid fish
Karvonen, Anssi; Lindström, Kai (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 2018)Parasitism is considered a major selective force in natural host populations. Infections can decrease host condition and vigour, and potentially influence, for example, host population dynamics and behavior such as mate ... -
Interactions between two parasites of brown trout (Salmo trutta) : Consequences of preinfection
Gopko, Mikhail; Chowdhury, Motiur; Taskinen, Jouni (John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 2018)Preinfection by one parasitic species may facilitate or by contrast hamper the subsequent penetration and/or establishment of other parasites in a host. The biology of interacting species, timing of preinfection, and dosage ... -
Divergent parasite infections in sympatric cichlid species in Lake Victoria
Karvonen, Anssi; Wagner, Catherine E.; Selz, Oliver M.; Seehausen, Ole (Wiley-Blackwell Publishing Ltd., 2018)Parasitism has been proposed as a factor in host speciation, as an agent affecting coexistence of host species in species‐rich communities and as a driver of post‐speciation diversification. Young adaptive radiations of ... -
Differences in parasite community composition support ecological differentiation in a freshwater gadoid fish
Karvonen, Anssi; Horppila, Petteri; Kuitunen, Jere; Miettinen, Miikka; Ryynänen, Lauri; Marjomäki, Timo J. (John Wiley & Sons, 2022)Several northern freshwater fishes have gone through rapid adaptive radiation after the last glacial period, resulting in new species or intraspecific morphs with distinct life histories. Parasite infections can promote ...