The Indeterminacy of Precedent : Negotiating the Admissibility of Victim Participant Testimony before the International Criminal Court
D’hondt, S., Pérez-León-Acevedo, J. P., & Barrett, E. (2022). The Indeterminacy of Precedent : Negotiating the Admissibility of Victim Participant Testimony before the International Criminal Court. International Criminal Law Review, 22(5-6), 1068-1093. https://doi.org/10.1163/15718123-bja10082
Published inInternational Criminal Law Review
© Brill, 2022
The icc represents a legal laboratory that is still consolidating itself, with multiple unclarities in evidence and procedural law requiring resolution through jurisprudence. Our paper draws on interaction analysis to unpack this process, focusing on the jurisprudential construction of ‘dual status’ victim participant testimony. To elucidate how this evidentiary/procedural element is locally negotiated, we examine an excerpt from the Ongwen hearing transcripts, in which the defense objects against the testimony by a dual status witness called by the victim participants’ legal representative. The analysis traces how the defense counsel’s objection is anchored in a trajectory of prior decisions, and demonstrates that the implementation of the criteria drawn from these decisions is mediated by deep-rooted common-sense assumptions about the ‘ownership’ of testimony. These unspoken assumptions open up a discursive space in which trial actors can discuss the interactional quality of testimony, which adds an element of contingency to the final decision. ...
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Evidence About Harm : Dual Status Victim Participant Testimony at the International Criminal Court and the Straitjacketing of Narratives About Suffering D’hondt, Sigurd; Pérez-León-Acevedo, Juan-Pablo; Ferraz de Almeida, Fabio; Barrett, Elena (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2022)Although victims at the International Criminal Court (ICC) are not parties, they can apply to become “victim participants” and may be authorized by an ICC Chamber to directly and orally express their views and concerns in ...
D’hond, Sigurd (University of Chicago Press, 2019)This article elucidates the role of metapragmatic devices like footing and stance-taking in trial hearings before the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague. It focuses on the case of Ahmad al Faqi al Mahdi, a ...
Victims and appeals at the International Criminal Court (ICC) : evaluation under international human rights standards Perez-Leon-Acevedo, Juan-Pablo (Routledge, 2021)Scholars have examined victim participation and reparations at the ICC. Nevertheless, no academic study focuses on victim participants and victims as parties (reparations claimants) in ICC appeals under international human ...
Weaving the threads of international criminal justice : The double dialogicity of law and politics in the ICC al-Mahdi case D’hondt, Sigurd; Dupret, Baudouin; Bens, Jonas (Elsevier, 2021)In this paper, we examine the international criminal trial of Ahmad al-Faqi al-Mahdi, a Malian Islamist who appeared before the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague, charged with the destruction of Islamic shrines ...
One confession, multiple chronotopes : The interdiscursive authentication of an apology in an international criminal trial D’hondt, Sigurd (John Wiley & Sons, 2021)This paper presents an interdiscursive analysis of a public apology made before the International Criminal Court (ICC) by a Malian Islamist accused of the destruction of cultural heritage in Timbuktu. It analyzes (a) how ...