Closed Theories, Falsificationism and Non-Cumulative Progress
Firsova, S., Bilorus, T., & Aksom, H. (2020). Closed Theories, Falsificationism and Non-Cumulative Progress. Problemos, 98, 125-135. https://doi.org/10.15388/Problemos.98.11
© Svitlana Firsova, Tetiana Bilorus, Herman Aksom, 2020. Published by Vilnius University Press
It is argued that scientific progress occurs not with the cumulative growth of knowledge or when theories get closer to the truth but with discovering new domains and new theories that fit these domains. This horizontal view on the direction of scientific progress (in contrast to vertical, when we aim to get from here to the abstract and ephemeral truth) allows avoiding traditional objections posed by the incommensurability thesis and pessimistic induction, namely, that radical theory changes leave no room for progress. According to this perspective, the discovery of quantum mechanics as a new field of inquiry is a progress in itself, since this discovery had opened up a new distinctive domain of physics and a new theory that fits this domain. While some perspectives on scientific progress maintain that there is a need for correspondence between competing theories, we shift the emphasis from correspondence towards the discovery of new domains and new theories that apply to those domains. This approach allows overcoming the problem of theoretical discontinuity after scientific revolutions. Correspondence between theories is an important but not necessary condition for progress, while the falsifiability of theories as a means of demonstrating the boundaries of old theories and domains and beginnings of the new domains and theories (instead of being merely a means of refutation) is a necessary condition. ...
PublisherVilnius University Press
Publication in research information system
MetadataShow full item record
- Kauppakorkeakoulu 
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Siponen, Mikko; Klaavuniemi, Tuula (Springer, 2021)Generally, to publish a paper in a top IS journal, making a new theory contribution is, so we are told, required. Such a requirement also exists in Design Science Research (DSR) literature. We review a number of claims ...
Aksom, Herman; Firsova, Svitlana (Springer, 2021)Organizational research constitutes a differentiated, complex and fragmented field with multiple contradicting and incommensurable theories that make fundamentally different claims about the social and organizational ...
Hartimo, Mirja (Routledge, 2019)
Siponen, Mikko; Klaavuniemi, Tuula (Association for Information Systems, 2019)IS theory accounts have increased our understanding of scientific theories. However, many influential theory accounts in Information Systems (IS) are influenced by the Received View of scientific theory (RV), which flourished ...
Siponen, Mikko; Klaavuniemi, Tuula (Elsevier, 2020)The hypothetico-deductive (H-D) method is reported to be common in information systems (IS). In IS, the H-D method is often presented as a Popperian, Hempelian, or natural science method. However, there are many fundamental ...