The potential biodiversity effects of voluntary peatland conservation in Finland
Nieminen, E., Kotiaho, J., Kareksela, S. and Halme, P. (2018). The potential biodiversity effects of voluntary peatland conservation in Finland. 5th European Congress of Conservation Biology. doi: 10.17011/conference/eccb2018/107936
Date
2018Copyright
© the Authors, 2018
Extending conservation area networks is one of the most important measures in the struggle against biodiversity loss. Many areas with high conservation effect locate in privately owned land so establishing new protected areas on private land is often seen necessary. In many countries, protection of private land has traditionally been top-down controlled and landowners have had little or no power to affect conservation decisions. A good example is European Union’s Natura 2000 programme that led to conservation conflicts locally. To avoid conflicts and to increase acceptability of new protected areas located in privately owned land, many voluntary and incentive-based conservation measures have been already widely applied. Many scientific papers report of successful protection through voluntary measures and celebrate their ability to make conservation socially more acceptable. However, voluntary measures do not affect only the social aspects of conservation, but also the biodiversity representation, by limiting the different options for protection. We studied the second phase of Finnish Peatland Conservation Programme that was originally planned to be implemented as a statutory programme enabling land expropriations, but was later changed as a programme of voluntary protection. We constructed three structurally different spatial prioritization analyses for three different scenarios: 1. Total acceptance; the analysis removes all the opposed peatlands from the solution despite their biodiversity representation. 2. Partial acceptance; the analysis considers landowners’ resistance as a continuous variable seeking a balance between resistance and biodiversity’s irreplaceability, while trying to maximize biodiversity representation with connectivity considerations. 3. Forced protection; the analysis maximises biodiversity representation and connectivity without considering landowners’ resistance to protection. Preliminary results show that demanding landowners’ total acceptance in peatland protection means a solution with significantly lower biodiversity representation for legal protection than the two other solutions. Instead, considering landowners’ acceptance partially leads to the solution that enables protection of practically as much biodiversity as forced protection. Our study shows that when high quality substitutive areas do not exist, categorical consideration of landowners’ resistance to protection leads to inefficient use of conservation resources. To avoid this, the ecologically most valuable areas should be allowed to be protected in spite of landowners’ opinion. Our results also indicate that a great deal of landowners’ resistance can be considered without a major decline in biodiversity representation in the solution, if conservation planners integrate landowners’ opinions as part of a planning process from the very beginning.
...
Publisher
Open Science Centre, University of JyväskyläConference
ECCB2018: 5th European Congress of Conservation Biology. 12th - 15th of June 2018, Jyväskylä, Finland
Original source
https://peerageofscience.org/conference/eccb2018/107936/Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
- ECCB 2018 [712]
License
Related items
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
-
Do small protected habitat patches within boreal production forests provide value for biodiversity conservation? : A systematic review protocol
Häkkilä, Matti; Savilaakso, Sini; Johansson, Anna; Sandgren, Terhi; Uusitalo, Anne; Mönkkönen, Mikko; Puttonen, Pasi (BioMed Central Ltd., 2019)Background Forest harvesting is the main driver of habitat degradation and biodiversity loss in forests of the boreal zone. To mitigate harmful effects, small-scale habitats with high biodiversity values have been protected ... -
Hydrology LIFE - conservation of peatlands and small water bodies in Finland
Haapalehto, Tuomas (Open Science Centre, University of Jyväskylä, 2018)Wetlands are biodiversity hotspots and provide many globally important ecosystem services, such as carbon storage and control of water circulation. However, they are badly degraded by human land-use and are, therefore, ... -
Are small protected habitat patches within boreal production forests effective in conserving species richness, abundance and community composition? : a systematic review
Häkkilä, Matti; Johansson, Anna; Sandgren, Terhi; Uusitalo, Anne; Mönkkönen, Mikko; Puttonen, Pasi; Savilaakso, Sini (BioMed Central, 2021)Background: In boreal zone forest management is changing and degrading forest habitats, which has caused declines in biodiversity. To mitigate these harmful effects in production forests, small-scale habitats with high ... -
Aquatic effects of peat extraction and peatland forest drainage : a comparative sediment study of two adjacent lakes in Central Finland
Kauppila, T.; Ahokas, T.; Nikolajev-Wikström, L.; Mäkinen, J.; Tammelin, M. H.; Meriläinen, Jarmo J. (Springer, 2016)The aquatic effects of forestry practices and peat extraction continue to cause serious concerns. The effect mechanisms of peat extraction on water quality and aquatic ecology of the receiving surface waters are well known, ... -
EFFECTS OF FARMLAND AND FOREST PRACTICES ON BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION IN NORTH-WEST SPAIN
Goded, Sandra; Ekroos, Johan; Domínguez, Jesús; Giménez, Joaquín; Guitián, José Ángel; Smith, Henrik (Open Science Centre, University of Jyväskylä, 2018)The main changes in land use during the last 50 years have been agricultural intensification and forestry plantations with exotic species, and North-West Spain is not an exception. Traditionally, local people used to give ...