Can experts identify "open throat" technique as a perceptual phenomenon?
Mitchell, H. F. & Kenny, D. T. (2006). Can experts identify "open throat" technique as a perceptual phenomenon? Musicae Scientiae, 10(1), 33-57.
Singing pedagogues have identified "open throat" as a widely used pedagogical tool in the singing studio and a critical technique to achieve good classical vocal quality. This study is the first to assess the perceptual validity of open throat. Fifteen expert singing pedagogues assessed 48 messa di voce and 24 song samples with six repeats of six advanced singing students under two conditions: "optimal" (O), representing use of maximal open throat technique and "sub-optimal" (SO), representing reduced open throat. Correctly identified responses were counted by condition (O/SO), by judge and by singer. Data were analyzed using Cohen's Kappa. Hypotheses that correct identification would be greater than chance were confirmed for both messa di voce and the song samples, with thirteen of the fifteen judges correctly identifying 82.7% of song samples as O or SO. Singers' self-ratings attributed their best singing to maximal use of open throat technique. These results indicate that listeners are consistent in making a dichotomous choice in identifying use of a singing technique through auditory-perceptual evaluation. The findings from this study suggest that there is a sound quality associated with the use of open throat technique, which is a perceptual reality to singing pedagogues and singers and that the specific vocal quality in classical singing that it produces can be reliably identified by expert listeners. If singers and expert listeners' of singing accord, focussing future research on specific singing techniques could enhance singing pedagogy. ...
MetadataShow full item record
Showing items with similar title or keywords.
Perceptual contents : a study on the nature of the contents of perceptual experience Oinas, Simo (2013)The aim of the thesis is to examine various views that have been advocated in contemporary discussions concerning the content of perceptual experiences. The nature of the contents posited in those views is the focus of ...
Expert views on home/family -related factors that can support or hinder children's critical reading skill development – A Delphi survey study dataset Torppa, Minna; Paakkari, Leena; Ruotsalainen, Jenni; Salminen, Jenni; Manu, Mari; Lahti, Henri; Kulmala, Markus; Raittila, Tiia-Liina (University of Jyväskylä, 2023)Data was collected using Delphi technique with three rounds: The 1st round:The first round included two open-ended questionnaires in which experts were asked to list (a) family factors that support critical reading ...
Biomechanics in cross-country skiing skating technique and measurement techniques of force production Ohtonen, Olli (2019)Requirements of a successful skier have changed during last decades due to e.g. changes in race forms and developments of equipment. The purpose of this thesis was to clarify in four Articles (I-IV) what are the requests ...
Astroturfing as a global phenomenon Haikarainen, Johanna (2014)
Superconvergence phenomenon in the finite element method arising from averaging gradients Křižek, Michal; Neittaanmäki, Pekka (Springer, 1984)We study a superconvergence phenomenon which can be obtained when solving a 2nd order elliptic problem by the usual linear elements. The averaged gradient is a piecewise linear continuous vector field, the value of which ...